Transmitting a language implies ... a subject and an Other

Sharon Wilsie proposes that horses transmit a language from mother to foal and that this language, along with nuances and an appreciation of context, has to be learned by foals in order for them to become horses, in order to become members of the herd. She is not alone, nor the first to say this, but, let's underline a couple of things: the language is not automatic; its elements can have more than one meaning and require an effort of reading. The language, according to Sharon, is linked to points on the body. This implies that the foal becomes a thinking agent with the mother's tongue literally licking the body, but the language she uses implies that both the foal and the mare have one foot in an Other. This goes beyond instinct, outside the bounds of signs, and includes a social bond. There are similarities here with humans. Sometimes when young horses are taken rather early from their mothers and raised in a group of other youngsters, as can happen when humans get involved,...